P20 Steel Comparison: DIN 1.2311 vs. DIN 1.2312 vs. DIN 1.2738 – Choosing the Right Plastic Mold Steel in India
In the demanding field of plastic injection molding, the selection of the right tool steel is not merely a material choice—it is a strategic decision that directly influences production speed, part quality, tool longevity, and ultimately, profitability. Among the most widely used materials for mold construction are the “P20 family” of pre-hardened steels. However, not all P20-type steels are created equal. Understanding the subtle but critical differences between grades ( P20 Steel Comparison) like DIN 1.2311, DIN 1.2312, and DIN 1.2738 is essential for any toolroom manager, mold designer, or production engineer looking to optimize their operations.
Welcome to Milano Special Steel, your trusted partner and India’s premier importer and supplier of specialty tool steels. With a legacy of over 50 years, established in 1972, we have cultivated an unparalleled depth of metallurgical knowledge. We don’t just sell steel; we provide solutions.
This definitive guide will walk you through a detailed P20 Steel Comparison of these three foundational plastic mold steels. We will explore their chemical compositions, mechanical properties, and ideal applications to empower you to make the most informed decision for your next project.
Understanding the “P20” Designation: A Family of Pre-Hardened Steels
Before diving into the specifics, it’s important to understand what “P20” generally refers to. P20 is an American AISI designation for a type of low-carbon mold steel that is supplied in a pre-hardened condition, typically around 28-32 HRC (Hardness Rockwell C). This pre-hardened state is its key advantage: it allows for molds to be machined to their final dimensions without the need for subsequent, and often distortion-risky, heat treatment.
The German DIN (Deutsches Institut für Normung) system provides more specific classifications. While DIN 1.2311 is the direct equivalent of standard P20, grades like 1.2312 and 1.2738 are considered variants or evolutions, each engineered with specific enhancements.
Deep Dive 1: DIN 1.2311 – The Industry Standard Workhorse
Also Known As: P20, 40CrMnMo7
DIN 1.2311 is the cornerstone of the pre-hardened mold steel category. It is the most common, versatile, and cost-effective grade, making it the default choice for a vast range of applications. It represents a perfectly balanced profile of properties that has made it an industry staple for decades.
Core Characteristics of DIN 1.2311:
- Excellent Machinability: In its pre-hardened state, 1.2311 offers very good machinability, allowing for efficient milling, drilling, and EDM (Electrical Discharge Machining).
- Good Polishability: It can be polished to a good standard finish, suitable for many consumer products and parts where a mirror-like surface is not the primary requirement.
- Uniform Hardness: It is known for its consistent through-hardness, though this can diminish in very large cross-sections.
- Good Weldability: With proper pre-heating and post-weld heat treatment procedures, 1.2311 can be repaired or modified via welding, which is a significant advantage for tool maintenance.
Chemical Composition Insights:
The key alloying elements in 1.2311 are Chromium (Cr) and Molybdenum (Mo), which contribute to its hardness and strength, and Manganese (Mn), which aids in hardenability. The carbon content is kept relatively low to maintain good machinability.
Ideal Applications for DIN 1.2311:
- Large Mold Bases and Holder Blocks: Its balance of cost and performance makes it perfect for the structural components of a mold.
- Injection Molds for Thermoplastics: Ideal for molding common plastics like Polypropylene (PP), Polystyrene (PS), and ABS where the surface finish requirements are standard.
- Bolsters and Support Plates: Used extensively in die-casting and forging die sets as structural supports.
- Prototype Molds: A cost-effective choice for creating initial test molds.
- Molds for Blow Molding and Structural Foam.
When to Choose DIN 1.2311: Choose this steel when you need a reliable, all-around performer for standard applications where extreme polishability or ultra-fast machining are not the top priorities. It is the king of cost-performance balance.
Deep Dive 2: DIN 1.2312 – The Free-Machining Champion
Also Known As: P20+S, 40CrMnMoS8-6
DIN 1.2312 is a direct modification of 1.2311, engineered for one primary purpose: enhanced machinability. The “S” in its alternative designation, P20+S, gives away its secret ingredient.
The Critical Difference: The Role of Sulfur (S)
DIN 1.2312 has an intentionally higher Sulfur content (up to ~0.1%) compared to 1.2311. In steel, Sulfur combines with Manganese to form manganese sulfides. These microscopic inclusions act as “chip breakers” during machining. They interrupt the cutting process on a micro-level, resulting in smaller, more manageable chips and reduced friction on the cutting tool.
Core Characteristics of DIN 1.2312:
- Superior Machinability: This is its standout feature. Machining speeds can often be increased, and tool life is extended, leading to significant reductions in production time and cost, especially on large blocks.
- Reduced Polishability: The trade-off for excellent machinability is a decrease in polishability. The same sulfide inclusions that break chips can be “pulled out” during polishing, creating microscopic pits. Therefore, it is not recommended for applications requiring a high-gloss, optical, or mirror finish.
- Poor Weldability: The high sulfur content makes welding extremely difficult and prone to cracking. Repairing a 1.2312 mold is generally not advised.
- Texturing (Graining) is Problematic: Similar to polishing, the graining process can be negatively affected by the sulfur inclusions.
Ideal Applications for DIN 1.2312:
- Large Mold Frames & Holders: Where extensive machining is required, and surface finish is not a concern, 1.2312 can save a tremendous amount of money and time.
- Machine Components: Used for various structural parts of machinery where fast manufacturing is key.
- Molds for parts with no cosmetic surface requirements.
- Pre-production or prototype molds where speed is more critical than finish.
When to Choose DIN 1.2312: Choose this steel when your primary cost driver is machining time. If you are manufacturing a large mold base or a component with a lot of material to be removed, and the final surface finish is not critical, 1.2312 is an excellent economic choice.
Deep Dive 3: DIN 1.2738 – The High-Polish, High-Performance Upgrade
Also Known As: P20+Ni, 718, 40CrMnNiMo8-6-4
DIN 1.2738 is a significant step up in performance from 1.2311. It is designed for molds that require superior surface finishes and for those with large, thick cross-sections. The “Ni” in its common designation, P20+Ni, points to its key enhancing element.
The Critical Difference: The Power of Nickel (Ni)
The addition of Nickel (typically around 1%) is the game-changer in 1.2738. Nickel significantly improves the through-hardenability of the steel. This means that even in very thick blocks, the hardness at the core of the block remains much closer to the hardness at the surface. In contrast, in a very large piece of 1.2311, the center might be noticeably softer than the outside.
Core Characteristics of DIN 1.2738:
- Superior Polishability: Due to its cleaner composition and uniform microstructure, 1.2738 can be polished to a very high, mirror-like finish. This makes it essential for producing parts with cosmetic appeal.
- Excellent Through-Hardness: The uniform hardness across thick sections ensures consistent strength and performance, preventing issues in deep cavities.
- Perfect for Texturing/Graining: The homogenous microstructure provides an ideal substrate for applying complex and detailed textures without imperfections.
- Good Machinability: While not as fast-machining as 1.2312, it still possesses good machinability, comparable to or slightly better than 1.2311.
- High-Hard (HH) Variant: We also supply DIN 1.2738 HH, which is delivered at a higher hardness (typically 34-38 HRC) for applications requiring even greater wear resistance and compressive strength.
Ideal Applications for DIN 1.2738:
- Automotive Components: Lenses, dashboards, interior trim, and grilles that require a flawless surface finish or intricate texturing.
- Consumer Electronics: Housings for TVs, laptops, and mobile phones with high-gloss finishes.
- Home Appliances: Molds for washing machines, refrigerators, and kitchen appliances.
- Large Injection Molds: Where consistent hardness across the tool’s thickness is critical for longevity and performance.
- Die-Casting Dies for Zinc Alloys.
When to Choose DIN 1.2738: Choose this steel when the final surface finish of your molded part is a primary concern. If you need a high-gloss, mirror polish, or a deep, uniform texture, 1.2738 is the superior choice. It is also the go-to steel for large and deep molds.
At-a-Glance P20 Steel Comparison : 1.2311 vs. 1.2312 vs. 1.2738
| Feature / Property | DIN 1.2311 (P20) | DIN 1.2312 (P20+S) | DIN 1.2738 (P20+Ni) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Advantage | Best Cost-Performance Balance | Fastest Machining | Best Polishability & Through-Hardness |
| Machinability | Good | Excellent | Good |
| Polishability | Good | Fair / Poor | Excellent |
| Weldability | Good | Poor / Not Recommended | Good |
| Through-Hardness | Good (in small/medium sections) | Good (in small/medium sections) | Excellent (even in large sections) |
| Key Alloying Element | Cr-Mo | Cr-Mo + High Sulfur (S) | Cr-Mo + Nickel (Ni) |
| Typical Hardness | 28-32 HRC | 28-32 HRC | 30-34 HRC (up to 38 HRC for HH) |
| Ideal For | General purpose molds, bases | Large mold frames, non-cosmetic parts | High-gloss parts, automotive, large molds |
The Milano Special Steel Advantage: More Than Just a Supplier
Choosing the right steel is only half the battle. Partnering with the right supplier is what guarantees success. Here’s why leading manufacturers across India trust Milano Special Steel:
- Unmatched Experience (Since 1972): For over five decades, we have been at the forefront of the specialty steel industry. Our expertise is your strategic advantage.
- Vast and Comprehensive Inventory: We are a leading importer and stockist for a massive range of premium grades beyond the P20 family. Our portfolio includes:
- High-Performance Mold Steels: XPM Steel, XPM VICTORY ESR
- Corrosion-Resistant Steels: DIN 1.2316, 1.2083 (Stavax), 1.2085, and their ESR variants.
- Hot Work Tool Steels: H13 (1.2344), H11 (1.2343), 1.2714, and premium ESR grades.
- Cold Work Tool Steels: D2 (1.2379), DC53, D3, EN31.
- High-Speed Steels (HSS): M2, M35, M42.
- Engineering & Alloy Steels: C45, EN8, EN24, and more.
- Precision Services: We supply material in plates and round bars, and our state-of-the-art facilities offer custom cutting to your exact size requirements. This saves you time, reduces waste, and streamlines your production.
- Wholesale & Retail: We cater to every need, from large-scale industrial orders to single-piece custom cuts for small toolrooms.
- Pan-India Delivery Network: From our operational hubs in Gurugram, Kundli, Sonipat, Manesar, Bawal, Bhiwadi, and Dharuhera, we deliver to every state and industrial center in India.
Serving Every Corner of India
No matter your location, our logistics network ensures you receive your material promptly and securely. We serve all major industrial cities like Bangalore, Pune, Surat, Mumbai, Chennai, Ahmedabad, Hyderabad, Delhi, Kolkata, and beyond.
Our reach extends to all states and union territories: Andhra Pradesh, Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Goa, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Jharkhand, Karnataka, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Manipur, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Nagaland, Odisha, Punjab, Rajasthan, Sikkim, Tamil Nadu, Telangana, Tripura, Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand, West Bengal, and all UTs.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: For an automotive headlight lens mold, which steel should I use?
For an application requiring optical clarity and a flawless mirror polish, DIN 1.2738 is the definitive choice. Its superior polishability and clean microstructure are essential for achieving the required surface quality.
Q2: I have to machine a very large mold base (2 meters x 1.5 meters). What do you recommend?
For a large mold base where machining time is a significant cost factor and the surface finish is not critical, DIN 1.2312 (P20+S) would be the most economical and efficient choice due to its superior machinability.
Q3: Is DIN 1.2738 more expensive than DIN 1.2311?
Yes, due to the addition of Nickel and the cleaner steelmaking process required to ensure high polishability, DIN 1.2738 is a premium-priced material compared to DIN 1.2311. However, for the right application, the investment pays for itself through superior part quality and mold performance.
Q4: Can you supply these steels with a material test certificate?
Absolutely. We believe in complete quality assurance. We can provide a Material Test Certificate (MTC) with every supply, detailing the chemical composition and hardness, ensuring you have full traceability and confidence in the material you receive.
Make the Right Choice. Partner with the Experts.
Your next project’s success begins with the right material. Don’t leave this critical decision to chance. Let the experts at Milano Special Steel guide you. With our vast inventory, precision cutting services, and over 50 years of accumulated knowledge, we are perfectly positioned to be your long-term partner in productivity and success.
Contact us today for a detailed consultation or a competitive quote on your next requirement.
- Email: [email protected]
- Websites:
Milano Special Steel – The Foundation of Quality Tooling in India.